Just got dumped--learn from my mistakes everyone!

rjherche

Don Juan
Joined
May 5, 2004
Messages
81
Reaction score
0
Don't always try to do something different and exciting, because girls take it for granted; make sure she is reciprocating.

Alright I got dumped about a week ago. I had been dating this HB 8.5-9 for 3 1/2 months, and basically I got oneitis. So I started getting sappy with her and it turned her off. This I realized right after she dumped me, and we can all agree that this anti-challenge. I'd tell her that I care about her and **** like that far more than she would say it to me. It's no surprise in hindsight that it was lowering her interest level. There was something else I didn't realize though.

Now she was talking about the breakup to one of our mutual friends, and it turns out that I was trying way too hard to show her a good time in the activities we would go and do. I didn't spend that much money on her but I always planning something out of the ordinary. Why? I was fixated on not letting the relationship get stale, and I of course was afraid of losing her.

So what else was I doing? Subtle things that were anti-challenge. There was a club we used to go to, a classy joint that plays swing music. Worried that we were getting into a routine, one time I told "I'm going to dress up for you." So I dressed up really nice and wore a tie and stuff, when normally I'd just wear a polo shirt. She felt obligated to dress up too, and she looked damn fine. Yet I think she could sense that I was somehow trying to impress her, even though I didn't realize it.

I would take her to the zoo--an hour and a half away. She was gone on vacation for a week so when she got back I had a romantic dinner planned. I only bought her one gift in this relationship, a $5 gag gift, but I prefaced it with "so I was thinking about you today and I got you something..." of course she thought it was funny, and I thought I was doing fine because it was sort of a smartass gift. It showed though that I was trying too damn hard even though my natural humor was more than enough to keep her laughing.

I was always looking to put on a show for her, because I know women like it when you're funny and you're thoughtful. But she didn't reciprocate and there was no balance.

LTR guys, heed my words.
 

nishbuk

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 30, 2004
Messages
536
Reaction score
3
Location
MTL
Ditto. See my thread. I believe that much of this happened to me as well in my 6 Monther...
 

quest

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 15, 2003
Messages
1,179
Reaction score
0
so you got dumped by a girl, who didn't appreciate the nice things you did for her.

i think she did the right thing.

now she can go and find the next guy, the guy who on friday night says to her "hey, we'll just stay in and watch the <sport> tonight."

"hey, its nearly half time, i need a fresh beer and some sandwhiches."

at the same time, you'll be having the time of your life with a girl who appreciates you. don't let it get you down. don't change.
 

rjherche

Don Juan
Joined
May 5, 2004
Messages
81
Reaction score
0
Maybe I was just being a nice guy though? I really think I overdid it to a degree.
 

jprjrjr

Banned
Joined
Jan 19, 2005
Messages
621
Reaction score
1
I feel for you bro. When you TRY with a woman, they can instinctively tell you're trying to impress them. This puts them in the power position, and you don't want to have that.

Be respectful, but don't go out of your way trying to be too nice. Just go with the flow, and don't let her dictate the relationship.

This may sound chauvenistic, but a realtionship will NEVER work if the woman is calling the shots.

1. Don't try too hard.

2. Don't try to impress her

3. Be the lead in the relationship
 

nishbuk

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 30, 2004
Messages
536
Reaction score
3
Location
MTL
Hey. That's a good point too. I didn't think of that. But how do you keep it interesting without trying? Hmm....Going to have to work on that one.
Perhaps I just need to make it natural...so it's not "trying" anymore, it's just being me. :)
 

seroph

Don Juan
Joined
Jun 9, 2005
Messages
70
Reaction score
0
Location
Massachusetts
jprjrjr is right.

my gf said to me tonight that she'd just like to drive around. which is boring as **** to me AND people say to minimize the time in cars (which i agree with).

how do you avoid trying to impress her. i def. agree u shouldn't. but i don't want to just chill around and do the same ol' **** every time. i want to do something a bit more exciting and flavorful.

are there posts on how to be the leader in the relationship?

i feel like she's got control over me right now and it's uncomfortable like hell. getting it back starts with "ignoring" her for a few days with my own busy life, right? then call, make plans. and then go. and be the alpha that i am.
that sound right?
 

Sayajin_Prince

Don Juan
Joined
Feb 11, 2003
Messages
119
Reaction score
0
Age
48
Location
London UK
its one thing that should be debated more often, because i can tell most of us are looking for a LTR

so...


how do u keep a girl interested in you in long term?


what do u really need to do and not do?
 

frivolousz21

Master Don Juan
Joined
Sep 11, 2004
Messages
3,154
Reaction score
16
Age
42
Location
belleville, il
Just be yourself


dont change either....she didnt appreciate you..so what.

I am going to tell you this now..I almost lost my girl..because I hide some of my passion for her...I wouldnt be too sweet and guess what? she felt like I was pushing her away.

so dont change..dont impress her with an act...impress her with yourself :)
 

Joe The Homophobe

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 8, 2004
Messages
1,214
Reaction score
8
Location
USA
Originally posted by quest
so you got dumped by a girl, who didn't appreciate the nice things you did for her.
I hope this serves as a lesson FOR ALL YOU NOOB MEISTERS OUT THERE!

Don't treat your girlfriend like a queen. Logic says if you treat someone right they love you the more for it, but remember GIRLS AREN'T VERY LOGICAL AND THEY LACK COMMON SENSE!
 

nishbuk

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 30, 2004
Messages
536
Reaction score
3
Location
MTL
Originally posted by frivolousz21
so waht should we treat her like?
Respect. But you have to show her that she's not to expect you to do everything for her. You are no lapdog. Treat your woman like a Queen, and watch her lose interest. Treat her like a normal person, and make her work for your attention, and watch her stick around. I did this perfectly for the first 3-4 months, and I lost it the last 3. At soon as I started having oneitis, being there whenever and whereever she wanted, calling her when I wanted to etc. She lost interest. They need to be challenged by real men.

Your post in my last "I got dumped" thread may have been true to some extent, but the REAL truth is that, A girl WILL FIND A WAY to connect with you on "enough emotional levels" if she thinks you are a great guy.
There is a REASON that there are a select few guys that NEVER get dumped.

1) They don't go out with girls with low interest (my mistake)
2) They know how to keep interest high until THEY are ready to break up.

These are the Don Juans. And I'm not one of them yet...

In my situation, I'm sorry, I don't care what comes out of her mouth, "I think you're a really great guy, and that's why I'm trying to love you, but I'm not madly in love with you, I just don't feel that way"...BLAH BLAH BLAH.

Bottom line, She was no longer interested in me, she was not attracted to me, her interest level plummeted because: altogether now:

SHE DIDN'T THINK I WAS A GREAT GUY ANYMORE, I WAS NO LONGER WORTH HER TIME. I WAS TOO EASY, NO FUN, NO CHASE.

Game Over. Time to move on for me. Why shouldn't have I treated her like a queen? Because she is NOT a queen. That's why.
 

Kaine

Senior Don Juan
Joined
Nov 11, 2004
Messages
475
Reaction score
1
Location
In your head
rjherche:

There's nothing wrong with mixing things up and keeping things exciting. However you need to do it in a non supplicating way.

When you said:
"I'm going to dress up for you"

This is supplication. If you do something to impress her, the last thing you should do is verbalise it!

You are also very correct when you observed that the balance was out of whack.

Your problem is that you were continuingly reducing your value by been anti challenge. What you were lacking was a way to balance things up again and that is to get her to work for you. If she doesn't have to chase you a little then she will gradually become increasingly emotionally bored with you no matter how exciting your plans maybe. You've become the dreaded "nice guy"

Keep up your fun and humor up BUT next time, try not to come off as trying to win her approval and MOST importantly let her chase you.

The easiest way to do that is to let her do things for you i.e. massages, cooking, making plans.


Kaine
 

sk24iam

Don Juan
Joined
Jun 13, 2005
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Hmm... When I take girls out I always try to make the event out of the ordinary and different. For t he most part I've had good results with this. Usually instead of planning these events and letting the girl I'm taking out what were doing, it's more of a sponaneous thing. Anyway, seems like your girl wanted you to act more like a jerk to her and tease her every once in awhile. But hey, now you're single and can get back to your game.
 

Maximus_Decimus

Don Juan
Joined
Feb 10, 2003
Messages
183
Reaction score
5
Originally posted by rjherche
I was always looking to put on a show for her, because I know women like it when you're funny and you're thoughtful. But she didn't reciprocate and there was no balance.
You can reciprocate and show her affection after she has earned it.

Maximus_Decimus
 

quest

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 15, 2003
Messages
1,179
Reaction score
0
so many people on this board.

so many people clueless.

"don't try and impress her"

listen guys, if you like sky diving, deep sea diving, riding motorbikes and other things of the like, taking your girl along ISN'T trying to impress her.

do the stuff that you find fun, and if your girl finds it fun aswell, she'll stick around.

the original poster's ex DIDN'T find it fun. she probably likes watching dvd's and talking to your mum. is that the kind of girl you want?

and to the guys who do like watching dvd's (even worse, movies they download before they've been released + playing XBOX/PS2) the bad news is, inviting a girl to share in with your fun will only ruin you anyway.
 

Carpe_Diem

Don Juan
Joined
Jul 22, 2005
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
Age
44
Location
Brisbane Aus.
i got dumped last night. Every thing was right as far as i knew, then i get a letter dropped at my door by her friend out lining everything i had possibly done wrong, or that had gone wrong since the start of our relationship. She had never discussed these things with me at the time so i could explain them to her or defend my actions.

To me it looks like she is a commitment freak who builds up a whole bunch of arsenal, then when she gets tired of the relationship *BAM* she whips it all out. But **** her, im not taking that lying down.
 
Joined
Mar 28, 2005
Messages
30
Reaction score
0
Location
Pomona by way of Sacramento
To RJ,

She'll eventually realize what she has done and will be sorry.

I honestly don't think you should change because you did exactly what all girls "want" which is to be a nice guy.

I agree on the onesidedness of relationships being a telltale sign of breaking up, but don't let this turn into reasons to treat a girl like trash.
 

quest

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 15, 2003
Messages
1,179
Reaction score
0
Originally posted by Carpe_Diem
i got dumped last night. Every thing was right as far as i knew, then i get a letter dropped at my door by her friend out lining everything i had possibly done wrong, or that had gone wrong since the start of our relationship. She had never discussed these things with me at the time so i could explain them to her or defend my actions.

To me it looks like she is a commitment freak who builds up a whole bunch of arsenal, then when she gets tired of the relationship *BAM* she whips it all out. But **** her, im not taking that lying down.
if a girl dumps you by a letter dropped at your door by her friend, theres 2 possible reasons.

a) You're a freak.
b) She's a freak.

one of you is definently a freak.

if it is you, stick around here and you'll change your mindset.
 
Top