jester its so great to see someone who can just cut through the bs.
I am amazed at the amount ofpeople in these forums that do not appreciate deep philosofical discussions. Maybe it's just the way I am but I prefer this kind of posting rather than "straight to the point" things. This post made me think. It made me stray away from routine, from lazyness within my thinking processes.
Show me the person who is truly happy living on the streets i dont believe it for a second, it totally goes against human nature.
The important thing here is not that he will be living on the streets. The key thing is that he will be trying to fulfill his dream. What he is saying is not that he wishes to live on the street. He is saying that he loves music and IF NECESSARY he will live on the streets while trying to pursue his dream, while trying to succeed in the music business( at least that's what I understood so forgive me if I'm wrong).
Lord Byron? Of course Lord Byron was a sad. He strived to be unhappy. He constantly invented misseries so he could be a "true romantic". He was your typical AFC. Other romantic writers were just as unhappy as he was. Take Bécquer for example. His wife left him,became a lesbian (just like Ross) and he died poor and unhappy.
That doesn't mean that philosophical thoughts will lead you to unhappy lives. Sure Nietzche and Kierkegaard sure were unhappy. But what about other philosophers? Aristotle proposed a formula to reach eudaimonia (kind of,like, happiness). Aristotle believed that to be happy you should constantly make use of reason. However this was not enough,you also had to be healthy, rich (upps I guess street guitar players are not happy according to Aristotle) and not be a slave or a woman (yes Aristotle was sexist). According to this principles Aristotle was a happy man.
What about Ayn Rand, the creator of objectivism? As far as I know she was extremely happy.
Damn! I started this as a response to the negativism in which philosophical discussions are percieved in this board and ranted my way towards philosophic history. I am sorry guys. Let me leave you with this:
"It is to give a great value to one's suppositions to criticize others for what others say about them". Montaigne.
Alexis Zorba