I'm always baffled that guys can't seem to pick up on a girl's behavior when it's indicative of her not having interest in them, and then ask: "So, is she interested?"
Like, really - just reading this situation, it was glaringly obvious to me (and some of the other posters here) that she had low-to-no interest. How did you miss it? Let me show you what I'm talking about...
MikeAndIke said:
So here is the deal. When we take the train together, she is a totally different person than when we are at the store. She ignores me at times at the store, but I understand why. No one wants to sh1t where they eat. She has a rep to keep up and the attention of guys to maintain. So she can't be seen giving me crazy play.
So, she's being rude to you at the store? NOT INTERESTED. Even if she's trying not to let people know you two are interested in each other, a girl's not going to do a 180 on you by ignoring you at work.
Also, your reasoning for why she's doing it - to keep up her rep and attention of other guys - is bogus and false. She's doing it because she's not interested in you. Attention of other guys be damned, if she liked you she wouldn't care about other guys vying for her attention 'cause she'd only be looking for yours. Anything else is just an excuse you're giving yourself to save your ego.
MikeAndIke said:
I'm cool with that. When we take the train together, she is playful and talkative, loves touching me, holds my hand, plays around and laughs, in essence shows signs of interest. But when I call or text, I get the uninterested side. I am beginning to question whether or not there is any interest at all.
Okay, so she's playful, talkative, even possibly touching you... but is she kissing you or saying things indicating she wants to hang out with you by yourselves outside of work? NOT INTERESTED.
All the "signs" you said she's giving? Girls do those same things with guy friends of theirs. Unless she's kissing you or screwing you, none of those things mean anything. As far as calls and texts go, you shouldn't even be trying to talk to her by phone unless you're setting up a date with her. Texting KILLS relationships, and regular phone calls are only good if you're trying to be seen as one of her girlfriends.
MikeAndIke said:
The moves that I have made in order to get her to hang out with me outside of work have failed. I've invited her out twice, and both times she has flaked. The first one my have been a miscommunication issue, but the most recent one has me questioning this entire "thing".
So, you invited her out and she flaked? NOT INTERESTED.
Dude, right now I'm dating a girl who's a legit singer - gets gigs all over Hollywood, has been on TV several times, has toured worldwide multiple times, and is regularly doing things in her life that keep her legitimately busy. Yet, lo and behold: if I call her up today and ask her for a date next Thursday, she will show up on said day, on time, without the need for me to remind her or re-confirm. Why?
BECAUSE WHEN THEY'RE INTERESTED IN YOU, THEY REMEMBER TO SHOW UP.
This girl is not busy, and unless she doesn't understand English it's pretty hard to misinterpret the words "Let's meet up on (date) and do something)." The reason she forgot is because she's NOT INTERESTED.
MikeAndIke said:
As we were chatting alone on the subway one day, I seriously told her that I would like for us to hang out outside of our current environment (work and subway ride). I wanted to see if the interest was there. She told me when she was available and left it up to me. I quickly told her that I had something planned for us on saturday, and she agreed, only to quickly retract saying that she already had plans for with one of our mutual acquaintances (more hers than mine). I quickly shot back, saying that Friday was our day. She said that she gets out at 4 PM from work that day and that it "could happen". I took what I could and said that I would call her.
So, she told you the days she was available, and yet the two responses you got from her was that (a) she suddenly remembered she had something else planned, and (b) that it "could happen?" NOT INTERESTED.
At this point, you were grasping for straws, when you should have been doing what you said you were doing, which was seeing if interest was there. When she said she wasn't available for Saturday, you should have waited to see if SHE presented a counter-offer day and time. But instead, you shot back with something. Had you not done that, you could have seen right away if she was interested, 'cause interested girls always give alternative days and times for guys they actually want to see. And when they do, they give a definitive "yes" instead of a could-happen "maybe" answer.
MikeAndIke said:
Fast forward to Thursday, the night before our "outing". I calling her to confirm our "date". She picked up after the 3rd ring. I greeted her and exchanged a few words. She cut me off and said that she would call me back soon, but never did.
Didn't call you back? NOT INTERESTED. But we've already discussed this, so let's move on...
MikeAndIke said:
Friday rolls along and at about 6 PM, I texted her and asked if we were still hanging out that night. I am still waiting for that response. At about 8 PM, I made a final attempt at communication by dialing her up, but I never got a response.
Sooo, date day came and she didn't pick up the phone or respond to text? NOT INTERESTED.
By the way: for future reference, stop trying to confirm with girls on the day of the date. If they like you, they'll remember the date and just show up (or hit YOU up to remind YOU about the date). In fact, the REAL reason you don't want to re-confirm is to test her interest level. If she shows up without you reminding her, it means she has interest because a girl that likes you (a) can't flake on you, and (b) can't forget about the guy she's meeting up with that could be her future husband. And if she doesn't show up, it's because you were the LAST thing on her mind (if at all).
Finally, allow me to answer some of your questions directly:
YOU: Is there interest or not?
ME: No, there is not.
YOU: What could I have done differently?
ME: Eh, the dating co-worker scenario can be a tricky one. However, the easiest way to have dealt with it would have been to ask her for her phone number at the first sign of your interest in her, then calling her and asking her out, point blank. It would have saved you LOADS of time. It also would have benefited you to read the early signs indicating her LACK of interest (i.e. when she flaked on you the first time) so you could stop wasting your time going after this girl.
YOU: I feel like I have done something wrong because I have not been able to see her outside of work although I feel there is some interest there.
ME: You didn't do too much wrong - she's just not interested in you like that, and there's not much you could have done about it.
YOU: Maybe I haven't been able to stand out from all of my other competitors.
ME: So what? None of the other guys at your job are dating her either.
YOU: Believe me when I tell you, I am not a thirstbucket either. I don't frequently call or text her, and we don't see each other at work all the time.
ME: Great - but again, if she's not feeling you like that, you could be around her all the time or scarcely and it's not going to make much of a difference.
YOU: The only thing is that this girl has me confused.
ME: Anytime a girl is throwing mixed signals, just assume it's a "no." I'm sure some guys will be mad at me for saying that; however, my uncle is in sales and he taught me: "Getting a 'yes' will make you happy; getting a 'no' will bug you for a while; but getting a 'maybe' will drive you insane." I'm all for not driving yourself insane trying to figure out if a girl "might" like you or not.
YOU: Am I overanalyzing?
ME: Yes, you are.
YOU: Is there something here or not?
ME: No, there is not.
YOU: What can be done to "remedy" the situation?
ME: There's nothing to remedy - she doesn't see you like that. The only thing you can do is start focusing on a girl that DOES like you.
YOU: If I can't completely bag her, I would like to remain in her circle, seeing as she has potential plates as friends.
ME: Oh, so now you're relying on her to get into her circle of friends? Why not just go after them without her being in the picture? You two didn't end up hooking up, so she's not necessary at this point.
Hope this helps!