Originally posted by ManOMan
Becker
you can do whatever works for you, but you seem to be breaking alot of basic rules from this site
let me see
Finally, during this last lunch I had with this girl, we were talking about jealous BFs and stuff like that, and I flat out told her that I was not like that and I don't get jealous and possessive.
** Qualifying ** you are implicitly telling the girl "Hey! iM BETTER THAN other guys! give me a chance and see??" (this is how women see your words)
I think I came off as very un-needy. Also, after lunch, I walked her back to the office, she thanked me for lunch,
**you bought her lunch??** when you mix genuine interest in a girl, with trying to buy them with gifts and paying for food, you are pretty much saying "I will buy your affection"
do you buy guy friends lunch?
and I told her I'd be around in the next few days or so.
**What happened to challenge???** why are you so available to her?
After that, the only time I got to talk with her was two days later, when I asked her how she liked lunch and whether she could keep Saturday open for me, to which she replied "yes".
** SUPPLICATION **
Why are you sooo available for her on Saturday?? and why are you begging her to commit a saturday to you? why ask her about how lunch was? it sounds as if you are gauging her IL in you based on you buying her lunch.
After that, the semi-cold shoulder stuff started. This is all new to me, so I'm not sure how to handle it.
Im no DJ, nor an expert, but after reading this site for a while, I notice you have put her on a pedestal, and making it seem as if you are honored to be in her presence(sp?), when it should be the other way around.
I notice supplicating (new word for me LOL), turns women off, especially when its so formal and obvious.
The only advice I can give you is to stop acting like she is the gold, and you are just a peasant gold miner.
switch the scenario around a bit, throw her off, flirt with other women, do the "hot"/"cold" technique, and stop talking to her like you are TRYING to win her over
peace
Holy sh*t, ManOMan, you have a pretty darn good point there. It may be the way you sort of broke up my post into pieces, but you definitely pointed out some potential problems. Before I go further though, I have to tell you that I'm Mr. Rulebreaker around here, and so far, I haven't had problems with doing what I'm doing. I am convinced that part of it has to do with the fact that I'm dealing with a seriously hot girl here, and the rules must be bent a little bit.
The "qualifying" part that you talked about above sort of came out wrong (usually on these message boards, it's difficult to express exactly what happened). Basically, I told her that I had a jealous and possessive GF before so I knew how she felt. I told her that it can get to be overbearing after a while. Now that I look at it, it may not have been the best thing to get into, but as I said, I usually don't think too much before I speak.
I bought her lunch because I asked her out, and it was the first time we went out together. No big deal, and I didn't treat it like it was some big sacrifice on my part. I do buy guy friends lunch, but usually it's like we'll take turns treating each other.
Good point about the challenge thing. I wasn't THAT available. I didn't even see her the next day. Then the day after that, I spoke to her for 5 minutes. If anything, I came off as less interested than I probably should have. To me, showing too little interest is as much a kiss of death as showing too much. I mean, when you like a girl would you rather she not pay any attention to you or at least show that she wants to be around you more?
As for the Saturday thing and asking her about lunch, it was more small talk than anything. I just threw it in, and asked her "what did you think of the place?" and she said she liked it a lot, and I said "cool". Then, I told her to keep Saturday open for me, and she said ok. I never asked her, I told her. I think my only mistake here is not telling her that if she didn't want to do anything, she needs to let me know, and I'll tell you why I have had so much success with this. First off, it must be stated a certain way in a certain tone to be effective. Essentially I'm saying "look, no games, if you don't want to do anything with me, you're not going to hurt
my feelings". It shows that you don't need her to agree to go out with you and makes it clear that you are not all dependent on her.
Anyways, thanks for the advice, it was very helpful, and sort of allowed me to look at things from a different perspective. I definitely think you had a great point, and I'm going to try to avoid giving off too much supplication and qualification vibes.