This thread is a cool perspective. To think that you can over-compensate, if you are not socially "fluid", by having a nice body may just be chasing a rainbow or fantasy. This is enough to cast some doubt into going to the gym, using a P.T. to develop a body that will "solve all of the dating problems"....and save some time and money.
Anyone else can develop this line of thought further?
The other contrary line of thought, is that simply with the amount of threads on here. If you do a search for "muscle", or something related, you will find a number of BEFORE and AFTER stories, including Pook, which portray there were changes in the way women responded to him.
Imagine you are in a store and there is just strangrs there. What are people first going to know about you? Are they going to know how many friends you have, or your "social proof"? Sure, you may be funny, and make women laugh, but suppose they don't see you more than a friend or a clown? They are going to see your face and body first. If you can't get your foot in the door in the first place, then who cares about your bank account, what job your do, what car you drive or your social proof?
I'm going to include a thread here form another site that shows a 51 year old virgin who lacks two things his best friend has - in his own words: looks and charisma.
http://incel.myonlineplace.org/forum/showthread.php?t=13298
Read this thread carefully and tell me, if you are "socially fluid" like this guy claims and can make women laugh, and you listen to them and connect with them, why can't women see this guy any more than a brother, friend, confident, or even gay and keep rejecting him as a man? His best friend is pulling women and is the same age as he is. He says he simply looks better than he does and has some charisma.
I have yet to do a research here where someone claims to have a personal trainer or morphed their body in a way that would really look more attractive to women (and I'm not talking about body-builders or super-ripped either) and had worst or the same results than they had then before they started.