Yeah, beating people up doesn't get women's respect (only men's), it makes them sort of frightened of ya.
Back in highschool I was the big, tough, jock 'rebel' metal guy, and i would act tough and would rough up guy or two at school and nobody at the school aside me and one of friends could really fight (I wrestled he Boxed).
And I thought by reading some stuff from the DJC (and also ASF) that the rebel jerk guy could pull in the ladies cos they act super confident.
So I mean, I went out on a first date with a dozen or so girls, and I acted like I normally did (a bit unpredictable, creative, but also sort of a bold jerk too). Well I never really got a second date. And the girls always, always came up with a total bs excuse (i have a bf, not ready for a relationship) and then It hit me that the girls were sort of scared of me because I was just too much of a tough guy character.
Although, if you want to be popular among the guys, you should act like I did. I had a lot of friend, and legend still exists at my highschool to this day.
I mean, when you think about it, look at Tyson. A lot of guys have respect for him because he can destroy them, but women don't like him because he can -literally- destroy them.