I get that but EVERYONE is saying the same thing. If it was a mixed bag of advice ok yeah vet the responses but this just shows even the beginners know what you need to do here. You are way overthinking, the answer is simple. If you don't want her in her life don't have her in your life period. You're literally getting in your own way and CHOOSING not to do what you need to do. If you were thinking about your future self, with his future wife, would he look back and say you wasted time thinking about all this and wasting time on this girl?
A hand full of people with questionable experience as I've often found on this forum, many of the guys here giving advice HAVE NOT GIRL OF THEIR OWN IN THEIR ENTIRE POSTING HISTORY...IN fact with one poster I called him out on a post that said he would pay not to be alone Friday and Saturday nights and this douche was attacking me, the guy who has a live in GF, had a side GF who knew I had a live in, and another GF that overlapped them both for about a week or so. And I still dated other women during that time here and there....As I said, friends who have been close to the situation with much more details said otherwise, and one was even a female colleague who weighed in. And guess what, they were right, she was reaching out to reconnect/fish because she missed me. Not to manipulate me. Jebus...
SO I responded again since she was clearly fishing to see if my live in was gone or not, something that was a hang up for her and she thought I'd never leave her....Told her that she doesn't deserve to be ignored, after all she never ignored me, and I was having an affair which was 10 times worse than anything she ever did which turned out to be what she said it was. I told her it's sad we couldn't come to terms, but she'll always be a special part of my life and that although I don't stay friends with etc. I'm glad she reached out and is welcome to reach out once in a while. There was a lot more stuff I said, it was sweet, I meant it....
She said she was glad I didn't ignore her, she was honestly hoping that I'd respond back despite saying she didn't expect a response after the way things ended or really want one and that she was still sorry we couldn't come to terms either. That she would love to stay in touch and even would really like me to visit her if I'm allowed (I have a gf who is suspicious) or single (again fishing to see if I'm single yet and whether I left her...the invite is primarily for when I'm single but still an invite, she had told me before to message her when I'm single). Said she has a female room mate and is right on the beach (as in, stay with her...reconnect, have sex again when I'm single and maybe start over...).
Thing is I know a relationship with her would never work, she's too immature, but she is a good person, we had a connection and she will be someone I look back on fondly throughout my life. I learned a lot about life, love and relationships through her and I'd rather be on good terms with her than be enemies or let things have ended badly.
In any case, I'm glad I responded, and I'm happy with the outcome. The game is not all about sex, although that's still on the table with her clearly. She is hot (but crazy). But she was also a good friend who I cared about and still care about, and even the most jaded girl at work has conceded that this girl does really care about me. So she reached out. I wasn't about to ignore her. Like I said, she never ignored me. I'm glad I met her and wish her the best. It's never really over anyways....never...People touch our lives and time apart helps us see our own mistakes in relationships and what we really wanted.
One thing I did learn from her, my experience with her taught me, is that although I have had other plates before her in my relationship, latter part when I strayed, the girl I always really wanted was right here with me and always there for me, treated me well. Ultimately I won't pursue a relationship with this other girl, but I'm glad we both got closure. My conversation with her helped me move on. We both got some closure and are on good terms.