OP, sites like these draw nutty guys already. The guys often have no social skills or have been recently treated poorly by a woman. How else are they going to find a site like this in the first place?
But, when guys post about a specific situation where a woman is treating them in a questionable manner, 9 times out of 10 it means the chick is no longer interested.
No guy is going to post something like "Hey guys, my girlfriend and I had the best sex last night, she made me breakfast this morning and now we're going to the beach to hang out and then go see a movie. Is anything wrong?" Nobody has good interactions and then posts here asking for input. It's always bad interactions. So the negative responses are usually justified.