This.… She resisted because she was conflicted. A tug-o-war between her moistening crotch and “not sleeping with someone on the first date“. You assisted by choosing the wrong end of the rope. You should have continued to seduce and escalate. Come on man, she had her hand on your junk. She should cut things off, not you by going to sleep. No wonder she was hesitant to leave.
I think you blew it further with that follow up
text as you gave her no chance for her hamster to spin. Go silent and hopefully she comes back..
Don’t agree with the one poster. Never say sorry and don’t call her beautiful, etc. pre-sex because that places her on a pedestal.
I say this from experience with all the times I didn’t close back in the day. Probably enough to start a TV series called Blue Balls with several seasons.