I'll never touch one to my lips with that fruity plastic tip.
Anyways, my favorite cigar so far is the Partagas Black Label. I just got back home from enjoying one, and when I smell it again the next day on my shirt, I like that smell better than some of my colognes. My friends have commented on how good it smells too, compared to other stogies.
My super-sophisticated way of weeding out other cigars to find that one for the first time was to...
...just pick the darkest cigar in the store
I found a store with some pre-embargo Cubans though, which I am going to get when I get paid again, along with a cigar with a nice cocoa flavor.