and so it begins

ubercat

Master Don Juan
Joined
Mar 6, 2015
Messages
3,829
Reaction score
2,416
Location
Australia
Thanks Harry Don't have much time for books but I can workout in front of vids so I ve signed up for your OLD course. Overall agree it was a feeble effort. Few questions in bold

1. The "coffee date" is only supposed to be used for girls you meet online because you haven't had any public interaction with them. You actually met this girl out in public, so you should have proposed a dinner date or drinks (not a big fan of the "drinks" date, but still an upgrade from coffee).
Y do u like dinner. SS consensus is an action date or drinks basically coz if she doesn't want a 2nd drink yr done

2. More importantly: when you asked for her number, you should have just asked for the number and not proposed any kind of date. Then, when you called her a few days later, you would have asked for a date at that time.
so u d take the good convo let's continue it some time line?

3. On an approach, kinoing isn't necessary - in fact, it can actually lessen your chances of getting with her. She may LOOK comfortable with you being all in her space like that, but women have learned to get used to guys doing this despite how uncomfortable it makes them feel (basing this off girls I've surveyed - they get creeped out but don't want to be rude or hurt your feelings by telling you to stop). Flirting is perfectly okay, though.
interesting. In the 59 seconds book study is quoted. Cold approach with a Yr cute' line got digits 10% Adding a touch on arm got 20%

4. The "good friend" line? No bueno. Talking to her for too long? No bueno - once you got the number, you should have been gooooooone.
Totally agree I think it broke at this point

5. Even if you made the mistake of setting up a date on the spot, you set it up way too far in advance. Since you were already in the throws of asking her out, it would have been better to set it for a couple days later, like Tuesday or Wednesday. If you had waited to ask her out once you got the number, you could have called her Wednesday for a date on Thursday. The point is: once you actually ask for the date, it shouldn't be set up more than 2 days in the future, lest she become less excited about going out with you.
[Agree


6. She got you off the phone in 2 minutes because you were calling her to do idle chatter - no bueno. The phone should only be used in the beginning to ask for dates. If you're not asking for dates, you're wasting her time.
I d previously said I d ring to make arrangements. This call was to make the date

7. Based on what you're telling us your motivation was - i.e. to make her an "FWB" or a quick lay - she probably felt this and wasn't feeling you were genuinely interested. Which, if you weren't, you shouldn't have been wasting her time. I don't know if she close in age to you, but if she's over 35 she ain't got time to be messing around with dudes that just want to hit & split.
She had major red flags no job and smoker. Was about practice. So r u not in favour of spinning plates in the early days?

8. You kept talking to her after you set up the date? No bueno. Once the date is set up, you don't talk to her again until you're picking her up/meeting for the date. All that extra contact that you think she needs to increase interest in you... is actually making her LOSE interest. (I wrote a whole book about mistakes just like this, which you can find at the link in my signature.)
PH call was to re-engage after she'd cracked out over me not sending my FB

9. And then, you made the #1 mistake almost ALL guys make that causes a woman to change her mind: you sent a "reminder" text. Dude, she doesn't have Alzheimer's disease - she doesn't need to be reminded of a date, especially if she has interest in you. However, sending that text CAN actually cause her to re-think what that interest may be, and result in a cancellation. Which, in this case, is exactly what happened.
Many schools of thought on this one. Happy to try it yr way next time

10. NO WEEKEND DATES when you first start dating a woman. Fridays and Saturdays are "couple" days, and you two are not a couple yet, nor does she need to get am impression from you that you're already thinking about her in that light. In an ideal situation, you would have gotten her number on Sunday, called Wednesday and asked her out for Thursday or Sunday.
Agree
!
 

Harry Wilmington

Master Don Juan
Joined
Aug 19, 2012
Messages
1,201
Reaction score
204
My rebuttals to your bold quotes:

ubercat said:
1. The "coffee date" is only supposed to be used for girls you meet online because you haven't had any public interaction with them. You actually met this girl out in public, so you should have proposed a dinner date or drinks (not a big fan of the "drinks" date, but still an upgrade from coffee).
Y do u like dinner. SS consensus is an action date or drinks basically coz if she doesn't want a 2nd drink yr done
For starters: the majority of people on these boards are wrong. They're giving you advice based on what they WISH would work; I give advice based on what has actually worked best for ME, as well as observations of other people's failures doing the WRONG things.

All that to say - coffee date with online chicks is good 'cause it's cheap. If the date doesn't go well, you only spent 10 bucks. If you met her at a party and only talked to her for, say, 10 to 20 minutes, dinner is an upgrade from coffee (since you already talked to her before), but still not as much of an investment as an activity or drinks could be. Plus, you still don't know if you even want to TALK to this person long-term, which you're going to have to do in a relationship with her when you're not doing activity based stuff, and if you don't like talking to her, you're setting yourself up for an annoying relationship. Thus: dinner. It's the interview anyway - once she passes the first date interview screening, then the next REAL date you go on can have an activity.

ubercat said:
2. More importantly: when you asked for her number, you should have just asked for the number and not proposed any kind of date. Then, when you called her a few days later, you would have asked for a date at that time.
so u d take the good convo let's continue it some time line?
I don't say any kind of line to let her know I'm going to call, other than "Hey, let me get your number." Logically, she'll get that I will call her at some point because I'm asking for the number. Once I get it, I say "Great - enjoy the rest of your day" then leave. I don't want her to know I'm going to call - I want her to NOT know when I'll call her and want her to WANT me to call, which is an easier feeling to build up in her if I don't tell her I'm actually going to do it.

ubercat said:
3. On an approach, kinoing isn't necessary - in fact, it can actually lessen your chances of getting with her. She may LOOK comfortable with you being all in her space like that, but women have learned to get used to guys doing this despite how uncomfortable it makes them feel (basing this off girls I've surveyed - they get creeped out but don't want to be rude or hurt your feelings by telling you to stop). Flirting is perfectly okay, though.
interesting. In the 59 seconds book study is quoted. Cold approach with a Yr cute' line got digits 10% Adding a touch on arm got 20%
I don't know what book you're talking about. But again - I'm going off what works best for me. I'm also basing this off of friends of mine who are girls who say they tend to get creeped out when a guy they just met is trying to touch them. With that said: if you've said the "You're cute" line and she appears to be smiling and laughing in a flirtatious way when you said it, the body language read may give way to you being able to touch her in a non-sexual way like on the arm or shoulder... but again, you have to get some kind of read from her that it would be okay vs. touching her without any positive indicators.

ubercat said:
6. She got you off the phone in 2 minutes because you were calling her to do idle chatter - no bueno. The phone should only be used in the beginning to ask for dates. If you're not asking for dates, you're wasting her time.
I d previously said I d ring to make arrangements. This call was to make the date
Another big mistake. One, you don't tell girls you're going to call them to set up a date... which leads to: two, when you propose going on a date, you set everything up WHEN YOU'RE ASKING HER. I don't care if you accidentally brought up the idea of going out when you first met her - once it's out your mouth, set up ALL details in that moment. Telling her you'll call later to set up details is the quickest way to rejection city, my friend!

ubercat said:
7. Based on what you're telling us your motivation was - i.e. to make her an "FWB" or a quick lay - she probably felt this and wasn't feeling you were genuinely interested. Which, if you weren't, you shouldn't have been wasting her time. I don't know if she close in age to you, but if she's over 35 she ain't got time to be messing around with dudes that just want to hit & split.
She had major red flags no job and smoker. Was about practice. So r u not in favour of spinning plates in the early days?
I'm in favor of spinning plates... with girls you actually (a) like and (b) have a chance with. You don't practice on losers because you're trying to get with winners. Furthermore, it's not fair to the girl, who may actually end up falling for you. You'd be surprised how many guys start with a girl as "practice" and end up with her. So yeah - spin plates, but do it knowing all the girls you're spinning start out with the potential to actually be in a relationship with you.

ubercat said:
8. You kept talking to her after you set up the date? No bueno. Once the date is set up, you don't talk to her again until you're picking her up/meeting for the date. All that extra contact that you think she needs to increase interest in you... is actually making her LOSE interest. (I wrote a whole book about mistakes just like this, which you can find at the link in my signature.)
PH call was to re-engage after she'd cracked out over me not sending my FB
Fell for the trap, I see. No need to re-engage, she knows you exist; just wait until the day of the date, then talk about the FB stuff on the date.

ubercat said:
9. And then, you made the #1 mistake almost ALL guys make that causes a woman to change her mind: you sent a "reminder" text. Dude, she doesn't have Alzheimer's disease - she doesn't need to be reminded of a date, especially if she has interest in you. However, sending that text CAN actually cause her to re-think what that interest may be, and result in a cancellation. Which, in this case, is exactly what happened.
Many schools of thought on this one. Happy to try it yr way next time
Yeah... I did a whole 20-min podcast on this, feel free to check it out HERE

And this is just some of the simple stuff. I'm working on a program right now that explains all the moves a guy needs to make with a girl to get her to "girlfriend" status by month 3, and a lot of it breaks down to avoiding some of these small things here and there that result in her being turned off during the first date, first month, etc. But that's coming out at the end of this month - for now, if you need more help hit me up for coaching at the link in my signature. Hope this helps!
 

ubercat

Master Don Juan
Joined
Mar 6, 2015
Messages
3,829
Reaction score
2,416
Location
Australia
Thanks again Harry. I find its the details and small knacks that make things work. Your explanations have moved this thread from general to actionable advice. I m sure I m not the only one who appreciates it. :)
 
Top