Zebedee said:
We got on so well its almost as if we got on too well, we could talk for hours on dates about any and every subject and make eachother laugh due to being so comfortable around eachother and having so much raport. I think this is whats landed me in this situation.
BINGO.
More than likely,that is where you went wrong.
Talking for hours about any and every subject under the sun and being "so comfortable/having so much raport" with a lack of attraction will DEFINATELY get you friendzoned.
It seems like you were so busy "getting along" with her that your
manliness got lost and she felt as if she was just talking and gossiping with one of her girlfriends.
You said that you two could talk for hours on date
s...
plural.
So I take it that this thing of you and her getting together and talking endlessly for hours has happened more than once,probably multiple times.
If that's the case,then it's HIGLY UNLIKELY that you'll turn this around.
Warrior74's suggestion of separating from her for a while could
possibly work,but honestly,it wouldn't be worth it.
As Joe Stud said,you'd need more than a month to make it work. This may sound like a joke,but I'm completely serious......you'd probably need 10 to 11 months,possibly even a year.
The problem is she's gotten used to you acting and behaving one way,and that way is as one of her girlfriends. It's kind of like watching a tv show with a very famous character on it. You see the character every week for years,and you just gotten used to seeing him in that role.
Then once the show has gone off the air,if you see that actor in another show or in a movie,it feels weird because in your mind,he's still the same character he played all those years,kinda like Steve Urkel,or Kramer from Seinfeld.
She's gotten used to you being in the "role" of just someone she can laugh,talk,and be comfortable with,
not someone to be sexual/romantic with,and if you try to change that,it may feel
weird to her.
She'll try to continue laughing and talking with you as before,but now all of the sudden,you try to get sexual with her. Might make her uncomfortable.
You can still try the NC if you want,but still keep dating other girls though,because it'll be a while before you know if it's doing any good or not.