So let me first say I think Calzaghe was a great fighter. Most people say Jones in his prime would have beaten Calzaghe soundly. I actually don't necessarily agree.... I think its possible Calzaghe could have won that fight but it most likely would have been via close decision... but I do think Roy Jones would have been correctly favored. I cannot see how he would have destroyed a prime Jones... no way in hell...
You cannot compare the Roy Jones who lost to both Calzaghe and Hopkins to the prime version of himself. Aside from age there is the residual effect prior fights have on someone. Roy Jones had already been knocked out twice by the time he fought Calzaghe and an additional time by the time he fought Hopkins again. Hopkins late success is a prime example of not suffering that residual effect.. He was a great defensive fighter who didn't take the damage other fighters have. That and a spartan lifestyle allowed him to be successful.
I guess we'll just have to disagree. I don't have Calzaghe's numbers in front of me but I know he didn't score KOs or TKOs in his highest profile fights (Jeff Lacy, Mikkel Kessler, BHop RJones). I do think he hit harder than he is given credit for but I think its more the volume of punches he is able to throw versus the power behind them. I'd guess most of Calzaghe's knockouts are via TKO which stands for technical knock out (ref stopping fight, corner throwing in towel etc...) I know you know what that means but true knock out artists are able to amass a lot of pure KOs (knock outs). How many non technical knockouts does Cazlaghe have versus Dempsey?
Yeah he mainly has TKOs. Dempsey literally fought for his life. His story is also pretty fascinating. He hadn't eaten for days before his fights sometimes. F*cking beast.
Calzaghe had disgusting punching power. Later in his career he didn't put all his weight into his punches. I believe he landed twice the amount of punches against Hopkins, and also outdid him in power punches.
I'm a big fan of Jones. He was an assassin in his prime. Of all his opponents, Calzaghe delivered the most punches in a bout. Nonetheless, Jones scored more powerpunches. Which doesn't surprise me.
It would be interesting to see him against Jones in his prime. If a post-prime Jones could floor him in the first round, we can only imagine the bloody battle they would've had.