The way I see it. There’s only some officers that are very good in tense situations. If you only took those officers and got rid of the rest, there would literally be any police officers at all. And even those officers who are good in tense situations are t perfect so it would be inevitable just by the sheer numbers of police/civilian interactions for something to eventually go wrong again and become another Gardner/Floyd video. It’s just a matter of time in my opinion, especially with everyone on the lookout to capture that next video in essence.
Good point. first I think the biggest problem with policing in the US is that there are not enough police, and that they can not attract the kinds of quality people in law enforcement because the pay, and long hours, due to shortage, is too long. So you end up bringing in people that are not well suited to the job then 'hope' they develop into quality officers. Back when I was a kid and saw a squad car or had a situation where the police were involved, you ALWAYS had an older seasoned cop, and a younger officer that was on the job learning... you just do not see that much anymore. Being able to deal with stressful confrontational situations comes with practice and the best way to learn is from an effective quality mentor.
Another problem, which really isn't the fault of individual cops, is that their priorities are set by political leadership which may or may not be aligned with protecting and serving the public. Just this morning... I was driving into work and at a major intersection the traffic lights were out... it was a snared and dangerous mess... took me 20 minutes to get thorough that. Then not even a mile down the road, there was a check point set up ticketing people with expired brake tags... I am sure that the cops would have much rather been at the intersection directing traffic... you know... actually helping people... but the city needs ticket revenue... and that stupid check point was a priority that morning.
Cities have turned law-enforcement into tax collectors, so people do not see the police as a value added service, but just one more thing that makes their lives a little more difficult. In my home city of New Orleans, 75% of all murders go unsolved... car break-ins and thief is RAMPANT... and almost completely out of control... but godd@mnit.... if you park on the wrong side of the road, or are 5 minutes late to the parking meter, or if your tail light happens to go out and you don't know about it... you're getting a fvcking ticket. And if you are a victim of a crime, you're going to have to wait an hour for a cop to show up.
Regrettably, I can honestly say that in the last 20 years, I have never had any positive interaction with the police... NONE. I had a bike stolen and when I reported it the police I got b1tched out by the officer for owning such a nice bike. I have more stories, but don't want to post a wall of text... But I will share this one.
I was arrested a few years back under suspicion of DUI. What happened was it was late and I was driving home from work... I drove through a dust cloud and dirt got in my contacts... so a pulled off to the side of the road to try and rest my eyes and get the dirt out since I didn't have anything with me to wash it out with. Well I fell asleep... A cop comes by and bangs on my window, He has me get out, dance around doing sobriety tests, checking my documentation. Anyway I get cuffed and hauled into the precinct station. I do some more sobriety tests dancing around, about 3 different cops came in checking my eyes... more dancing around walking lines... standing on one foot.... they said they didn't see any indications... so I volunteered to take a sobriety test... and I had to correct the officer who said "If you don't take the test we are going to suspend your license for 6 months." I said, he was wrong, my license will only be suspended if I am otherwise found not-guilty... and since you don't have any evidence... I will not be suspended... but if this gets me home sooner.. fine. .000 BAL.... but that wasn't enough, they wanted to do a blood test... which I already again volunteers for... waited around sitting in handcuffs for 3 hours waiting for the results to come back. Well.... they came back and arrested me... took me down to central lock-up and booked me, (drug test was apparently clean but I didn't learn that until later). NO one told me what I was arrested for... I had no idea why I was in jail. I called my lawyer, and he came out and posted my bail ($17,000 don't get me started on why the fvck that was so high) and it was only then that I knew I had been arrested for
not having a valid driver's license. I told my lawyer that I gave them my license when I was taken in... and that it was indeed valid... he told me that Cops here do that sh1t all the time, they will just say you didn't give it too them so that they don't have to explain why you were arrested without any evidence for DUI.
Anyway I was ready to go to war over this, but my lawyer, while willing to take my money, said there was no way to win this, and even if we did and got a monetary judgement from a city, the city is broke and we would have to wait behind $25 million in judgements already on the books for a city that can not pay. So I settled for having the fine waved but continued to insist I didn't give them my license, and paid my lawyer for doing that... so I still lost about $1,000 for his services. Now if this can happen to a middle aged white man, wearing a suit, driving a $40,000 Audi... what fvcking chance in hell does a black teen age kid, living in the projects with his single mother have.... that poor b@sterd would have been sitting in jail for God knows how long, since he couldn't make bail, waiting on a public defender to get around to him... and would have been mixed in with really horrible people. And people wonder why innocent people run from the cops.