Advice from the old lady:
Self esteem is of paramount importance. The higher a woman’s self esteem the more attractive man she can handle.
I consider myself probably an 8 physically. Some men have told me I’m a 9 or 10, but it’s really so subjective that two different people will have very different opinions. I routinely date very attractive men who women compete for. I know I may not be the most beautiful woman these men can get but I also know that I am solidly the total package (sweet, smart, social, act together, pretty, slender, loyal, reasonable, respectful cool, etc.,) and so I am a “best” type woman. I know men will see and appreciate that so I don’t worry about just looks, although I keep myself in top physical form. I’m relaxed and not neurotic as a result, which in turn is attractive in itself.
Few women have high self esteem. The ones who have the traits I noted in combination get snatched up fast (and I see this as well)...I recently ended my 2 year relationship and I’m already bombarded with dates and opportunities. It’s overwhelming a bit.
This means I can afford to be choosy. But I’m also very relaxed. Just last weekend I had a hot buff guy hitting on me hard. He’s too young for me (I pointed this out to him), and he’s too arrogant. I don’t care for people who think they are God’s gift and whose ego is so inflated that they act like idiots. This guy ended up shoving a piece of paper with his phone number on it in my pocket, and telling me to call him. Ugh. No thank you.
So OP, as long as you aren’t acting like a stuck up baffoon like the man described above, you should screen for women who respond to you and screen for women who possess self confidence. I’ve dated a professional male runway model in the past (and men I consider better looking than him), and don’t get jealous really. Why would I? I know what I bring to the table and I choose from men who want me. If that changes? Move along. Next!
Up your criteria and go for hotter women. If you find the hot/cool chick, get to know her. Look for self esteem, confidence, and authenticity.
Those women are out there. And often they are delighted to meet a solid man.