It's just a fundamental misconceptions between
What is attractive to women (Red Pill) vs.
What you think should be attractive to women based on social conditioning and mainstream social narratives (Blue Pill).
So while an Alpha in Beta Clothes is an attractive archetype (think physically nondescript guy with super strong frame & game)--a diamond in the rough that maybe only she has discovered, a Beta in Alpha Clothes (the guy she thinks is super badazz but is eager to commit) is
not. He's 'broken.'
What
does work as an archetype for relationships is the just-barely-a-little-tamable-maybe Bad Boy who, due to her self-perceived uniqueness, she is able to capture the attention of--but just barely. Think every romance novel ever. And what works as an archetype for purely physical relationships is just being a badazz who won't commit to her at all ever & doesn't even care if she has some primary provider bf or whatever.
But both of those look the same way starting out.
Another mistake a lot of guys make is trying to be too perfect. That guy makes her too insecure for emotional investment & too potentially valuable for just sex--so usually the default response (for all but the highest self-esteem girls) is to flake out. It's far better to present yourself as a loose cannon--really sexually valuable (i.e. hot) but whose lifestyle is a deliberate mystery or who paints himself as super low status. I tell girls I cold approach that I work some super low status job, like fast food or a garbageman or whatever--but I say it like its the greatest thing ever. Like I'm totally oblivious to the fact that being a garbageman isn't the best job ever.
I drive a garbage truck--Well, I don't really drive it. I'm still on the back, but my supervisor told me if I stick around a couple years someday he might make me a driver.
And I'll keep that going as long as possible (usually to the point when a girl's proven herself worthy to really be a part of my life--and then I'll stage some really big 'confession'). It accomplishes several things: 1.) I know that any girl who still treats me well likes me for me 2.) It totally disqualifies me from being a provider or being judged as one 3.) It creates tension & mystery--why is this garbageman so confident? What else does he have going for him? He can't really be a garbageman, can he? Why doesn't he care about impressing me? But he has so many good qualities--maybe I can inspire him to do this, that, or the other.
Notice how many emotional threads/possibilities that creates as opposed to
I work IT in a corporate branch of some huge corporation and make six figures plus benefits and the reason I didn't text you back the other night wasn't because I was with another girl or at some epic party but because I go to be at 10:30 since I have to wake up at 5 for my morning commute. Now, at a certain point most girls
will want you to have that type of stability if you a pursuing anything longer term, but it's way more effective to relieve that tension on the back end than to kill it all on the front end when she isn't even sure whether she's looking for a relationship or not and dating an IT worker doesn't
feel like a very emotionally compelling narrative. Even tho
logically she
should be dating the IT worker instead of the garbageman lol.
Also, pay attention to what
@BeExcellent wrote regarding high self-esteem women. They are usually
way more flexible & laid back dating other people with high status & don't
need you to adhere to some cardboard cutout that she can fit neatly into her reality without risking her own identity. For example, they can date a high status man and realize he's still a man at the end of the day (whereas with lower self-esteem girls, the minute you show her you might have depth or even paradoxical qualities, she's probably gonna bail). HSE women are super rare, but they are out there & you'll know it when you see it. Personally, I enjoy them when I find them but don't meet them often enough not to enjoy the company of less secure women as well, even if that means being a walking dildo from time to time or playing into stereotypes. Just avoid getting too involved with girls that are super low self-esteem or Cluster B, since that's usually more of a headache than it's worth.