It really depends on the individual, each have their pluses and minuses, but if you are looking for a coach you first have to start with yourself.
Wayne: He's a life coach that teaches how to integrate the true nature of women into you life, and focuses on relationships.
Doc Love: The grandfather of true female nature. And also teaches how guys can get into relationships.
Mystery: Club and day game... this is a guy if all you are interested in is hooking up with as many women as you can. His stuff is about played out and really only works on young women.
DeAngelo: Don't know anything about him, but some of the stuff I've seen really isn't unique.
Strauss: Great book, but I don't think I would classify this guy as a coach... I think he has or had a company, but just lent his name to it. What was in his book was pretty much what Mystery teaches.
Deida: He's different, not sure if he is effective but he is more of a life coach with religious aspects. If you are comfortable with this sort of thing, you would likely like him the best. More of a life coach rather than dating coach.
Labyrinth: I sort of like this system. It focuses on going after ONLY high quality women.. I think this is the correct approach by focusing only on the very best it's more about quality than quantity.
Not on your list is Jason Capital, who I think is the best. He does a great job of getting to the point where many PUA and life coaches go on and on and on ad infinitum...... he just tells you like it is, in 5 minutes he explains exactly how and why attraction works... and how to make it happen, I've never used his product, but he comes off as honest and his promotional material is spot on.