Disco,
Jeez I think this is just about one of the toughest issues in dating -- when to first call a girl.
I've given this an enormous amount of thought over the years. Here's what I arrived at.
1. Almost always at least a week (seven days) before calling (unless, say, she's from out of town and she told you she's leaving in three days -- there are always exceptions....).
2. Never call on a Friday or Saturday (as lone-raider mentioned) -- you're in demand, you're out doing stuff, that's the impression you want to leave. But I would say not to call on Sunday, either, because Sunday is usually the day when people catch up those who are really close, like family and intimate friends. Also, I wouldn't call on Monday, because if you're super, super busy, Monday is the day when you catch up on business stuff that you couldn't get around to over the weekend. So that leaves calling on a Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday.
3. Also, never go out with a girl for the first few times on a Friday or Saturday night -- that's when you see chicks you are really into. So that leaves going out on a Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday -- or Sunday or Monday, but....
4. You should always test their interest level in you by proposing a day near in the future, like one or two days. For instance, you call on a Tuesday and ask her out for Thursday.
5. Call between 6:00 p.m. and 9:00 p.m. Maybe I'm more conservative than some guys here, but I think 9:00 p.m. is still considered the polite cutoff time for calling (that's the time when telemarketers legally must stop calling people).
6. Do not call on your phone. Don't call on your phone, because almost all chicks have caller ID, and you don't want her to see that you've called until you're talking to her. Also, don't set your phone to private call, that's sketchy for a GUY. That's like, in my view, knocking on someone's door with a ski mask on. And so I have long recommended calling on a pay phone.
7. Do not leave a message -- ever. Because you can't ask a girl to call you if you haven't banged yet. Someone might say, well what if she's never in and never answers her phone? Then that's HAPPENING FOR A REASON -- she's screening her calls. I've found that IF A GIRL IS EXCITED ABOUT A GUY SHE HAS MET, SHE WILL PRACTICALLY LIVE FOR DAYS ON END ATTACHED TO HER PHONE WAITING FOR THE GUY TO CALL. If she doesn't pick up, it means she's not living attached to her phone.
8. Do not call more than once per night. Christ, you're busy, you ain't got the time to call more than once per night!
*
So here's a case study.
You get a girl's number at a bar on a Friday.
You wait until not the next Tuesday, but the following Tuesday to call. So eleven days. You call from a pay phone at 7:00 p.m. If no one answers, you hang up.
Try back a week later, on Tuesday. If she still doesn't pick up, try again on Thursday. If she still doesn't pick up, try, say, next Wednesday. But after four calls, forget her. You're busy, you got stuff to do.
*
The thing is this -- the best approach to getting laid on a long-term basis is to work on your reputation. Always cultivate a reputation of being in demand, of having people coming to you, not you going to people. How awesome it would be if you met a girl once and got her number and tried her four times, but no go, and then a year later she sees you in a bar and she was into you at the time, and she'll basically light up when she sees you, AND OTHER CHICKS WILL SEE THIS, AND THEN ALL THE CHICKS IN THE PLACE WILL BE AFTER YOU.
The deal is, if you can get one chick to be mad about you, then others will follow because THE BEST WAY OF GETTING A GIRL INTERESTED IN YOU IS FOR HER TO SEE THAT OTHER CHICKS ARE INTERESTED IN YOU.
--BGC