I would proceed as normal. If not attracted once we meet, I will often use it as practice, kiss close, then never contact her again. It all starts with filtering better online. However, this will lead to many less matches online. I found that I was consistently going on dates with women that just weren't all that interesting, or had a feature that I couldn't stand to be around. I also realized I can show all women a good time and kiss close 90% of them. This means I was aiming wayyyy too low.
So, I have siginifcantly increased my standards on OLD (which isn't saying much) to only contact/swipe/like/message/etc. 8's and above... Now my return rate and mutual likes have gone wayyyyyy down, but I know I am at least attracted to these women. I was getting 2-3 dates a week, whereas now I get maybe 1 every two weeks.
I am not the greatest in looks, so I will not naturally draw the most beautiful women from OLD. However, I do converse well and am pretty witty, which is easier to put on display in person.