My Greatest Nightmare: Doctor Says I Should Stop Lifting Weights

Frank2500

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 22, 2006
Messages
638
Reaction score
19
Age
46
Hello Everyone,

Well, toward the end of last week, I suddenly began to notice that I was feeling much discomfort in my lower back/spinal area when I was seated for a long time. It wasn't a pain as such, but just some sort of pressure that used to make me feel uncomfortable and to want to stand up straight in an effort to relieve the discomfort. This week I noticed that I began feeling the same thing whenever I had to bend down to pick up something or do any strenuous movement that involved my lower back and of course, in my current office I feel the same strain on my back while seating. I remembered that last week I went very intensively on one of those rowing-type machines at the gym, and did 100 kg of weight on it to work my triceps etc and that I used it at least three times last week.


Yesterday I went to see a doctor and based on the x-ray results, she told me it could be the beginning of a herniated disc and that she advises me to completely cease lifting weights or anything heavy because as I continue doing so, the hernia (if it is the case) will begin to grow within my body and cause complications that may necessitate an operation. And here like in most African countries where healthcare is of such poor quality, getting operated is synonymous to a death sentence because the survival rates after being sent into an operating room are extremely slim. She said I should take seven days of rest off from work, prescribed a pain killer for me to take for 10-14 days and told me to do some physical therapy for a week (including getting massaged, etc). Now, this doctor simply did general medicine, so I intend to take my x-rays to a specialist in the domain to get his thoughts as well.


So guys I wanted to get your respective thoughts. If continuing to lift weights in case I'm able to treat this issue succesfully may cause more harm than good, what other kind of sports would you suggest I consider? Some have proposed swimming to me but the thought of losing all of this muscle I have worked so hard to build since 2006 really pains me. Nonetheless my health comes first. Others say I could still continue to lift weights/use machines but at very reduced weights in order to avoid any complications. I wish there were some other less strenuous method for me to either maintain or continue building muscle.
 

DanZy

Master Don Juan
Joined
Dec 11, 2011
Messages
626
Reaction score
18
Location
Johannesburg, South Africa
I injured my back, a compressed disc so pretty much the same as you, playing rugby about 3 years ago. I had to do a few months of physical therapy and it really helped. Mind you, going to back to lifting has helped more than anything else. I'm stronger than I've ever been and that's what has made all difference. I credit deadlifts with saving my back.

Remember that GPs generally know fvck all about lifting, most doctors know little about it. I was fortunate enough to be able to see one the best sports physician in my country though.
 

switch

Master Don Juan
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
947
Reaction score
38
Location
living in the middle of effing nowhere
ok there are a few key points:

1.your doctor is an idiot, nuff said.

2.it is most likely just a muscular problem,so dont worry

3.how in zeus's fvck did your doctor diagnose a herniated disk by an X-ray???
how dafuq? i really want to see your doctor and ask her about this phenomenal breakthrough...its like saying you made gold from combining silver and tinfoil....

thing is dude,in a x-ray you can't see the vertebral disk man, you can only see bone(vertebra), so she can at best diagnose vertebral fractures NOT herniated disks, bcuz she cant see the effing disks, what isshe? superman? or just delusional and pretends to see the disks? lol
you need an MRI or CT scan.

4. this doctor should have paid attention to your history : office worker, sitting all day in cramped conditions in the same form for 8 hours+, this is your problem, not weightlifting.

i bet a 100bucks that she said weightlifting is the cause....typical retarded low IQ doctor....most doctors are also overweight.

so to sum up ;
a.your doc is retarded
b.get an MRI or CT scan..MRI is prefered
c.weightlifting can heal your back , i was in a wheelchair ,now i run faster than my friends.
d.swimming is great
e.avoid machines, stick to freeweights (squats are best)
f.as danzy well said docs dont know jacksh!t, (except me ofc lol)
 

insomniac9

Don Juan
Joined
May 20, 2013
Messages
38
Reaction score
1
for the time being, i'd avoid any exercise (be it a free weight or a machine) that puts strain on your lower back, at least until the issue is cleared.

2nd of all, if 100kg caused enough damage/pain for you to seek medical attention, 2 things happened or at least one of them, which is:
a- weight was too heavy
b- your form was terrible

i'm assuming you lift weights mainly to look good & feel good, so you're better off lowering your weights, perfecting your form, doing higher reps & increasing your muscles' time under tensions.

good luck & get well soon.
 

Frank2500

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 22, 2006
Messages
638
Reaction score
19
Age
46
Re:

Thanks a million to you all for your responses and well wishes. @Danzy: what's the maximum weight you're able to lift right now (machine wise) if you don't mind me asking you?

@Switch: Thank you so much. I'll be on the way to see the back specialist soon and I have definitely taken your advise into serious consideration.

@Insomniac: I'm in pretty good shape. I don't drink alcoholic nor carbonated drinks, I'm not over weight and have pretty much maintained a flat stomach all this while, including my slimness. The only thing I don't really have that much anymore at all are abs, because of the lack of appropriate equipment overall where I am. Nonetheless, just like you, most folks have suggested to me that I should seriously consider reducing the weights I do. All right...I've got to get up now. Sitting for long periods of time and attempting to bend down to pick anything just isn't easy at all to do right now.
 

Frank2500

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 22, 2006
Messages
638
Reaction score
19
Age
46
Re:

Thanks a lot, Brad. I saw the specialist yesterday and after looking at the X-ray she equally said it might be the beginning of a herniated disc. She prescribed me more pain killers and said I should take them for two weeks and then return to see her. If I don't feel better then, she will ask me to get a scan done. It's not easy at all. The pressure on my lower back makes me feel like I'm almost about to develop a hunch back, as if it is pushing my back way forward than usual. The specialist also told me to not to get the back massaged as it may cause further unnecessary complications. Do you guys think getting some acupuncture done in my case may be a good idea?
 

JohnChops

Master Don Juan
Joined
Mar 9, 2012
Messages
2,762
Reaction score
492
Location
No more keyboard jockeying . Action is the place.
I have that pain after deadlifting heavy.... but my form in perfection. Its stress on the muscle of the lower back. Mine goes away the next day.

Ouch man, thats rough what were you doing? Heavy deadlifting with hunch back form or without a belt will do that. I dont think you have to stop lifting, if anything stop deadlifting and possibly squating. If I ever heard that news i think i would just end my life.
 

Frank2500

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 22, 2006
Messages
638
Reaction score
19
Age
46
Re:

@John Chops: I don't have a hunch back form at all but I was lifting heavy without a belt and the seats in my office aren't very comfortable and we sit on them for quite a while. Well, my own symptoms have still not gone away and I'm on pain killers, so I just hope it isn't anything more serious. I had asked if any of you guys think I should consider acupuncture?
 
Top