No I would totally just see it as a test. Laugh it off, be ****y funny, and bring up that one of her friends is a freak, etc. I wouldn't drop her, or end the date or anything like that. That only shows that it does bother you, and your not secure enough to take some comments about another guys looks.
Man up, and dust it/her off w. Stealing this fools thunder by being the man... laughing it off. Then direct the attention to some hot chicks. But I would suggest NOT doing it right after she brings up this guy. Then it would seem related, and would just appear that your trying to get back at her. Indicating that it really did bother you.
You could blend with her notion of this guy like this as well, accentuating his faults, lowering his value, stealing his thunder:
her: omg Doofus is sooooooooo cute.
you: he ain't got nothing on me... I'm the don juan dizzle (big cheeky grimace)... and whats up with homey's shoes!? Christ... those are god awful (passionately said in disgust, so that she wouldn't want align with liking them/him, and be seen in someone's eyes as she has no style either).
another example:
her: omg Doofus is just gorgeous
you: ya he's alright, sort of bland looking though. and someone told me he has a 2 inch c*ck. (lmao... at this point you could either laugh with cheeky delight, or bluff and totally stick that notion in her mind with serious intent.
you: for real... seriously... thats what I heard.
Then at this moment, pick her up in a big bear hug, and all with a smile and joking, and say... "he ain't got nothing on my nutz and bolt baby."
She'll laugh, and enjoy the fact that your confident/****y enough in your sexual power, and then totally fall back into you as the focal point... the man.
Then like 5min. later walking down the street... point out some smoking hot chick, and compliment something on her, that you really sincerely like. "Wow... she has beautiful eyes"... "what sexy hair"... "damn look at that chicks legs... must be a fan of downward dog"
Hahahaa...
Anyways... thats my angle on it'
DarkLight