I don't trust her

hamilton

Don Juan
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
52
Reaction score
1
At least, not when she's drunk.

About 2 months ago I started dating a girl who I've known for about 3 years. We are basically exclusive, she has asked about it a few times but I have held off on making it official since she might be moving away in 6 weeks. When I first met her, she was the typical crazy college party girl, drinking all the time. Now she rarely drinks. She told me this is because she doesn't like how wild she gets when she's drunk (in terms of hooking up with guys). Since we have been dating, we have gotten drunk together at parties 2-3 times. In those times, she has:

1) Kissed one of her orbiters (she claims it was right in front of me, but I don't remember seeing it)
2) Another one of her orbiters made out with her

I didn't see either of these occurrences, I heard about them afterwards through her. And honestly, I don't care. The other night, however, she got drunk and went out without me there. Later that night, we were lying in her room talking, and she said something to the effect of "I'm so glad I didn't mess this up by doing something dumb and sleeping with someone else tonight". This actually bothered me, which surprised me because it means I care about this girl more than I thought. She didn't remember anything in the morning. I didn't want to tell her about it, but apparently I was acting a bit weird in the morning and she knew something was up so I told her. She actually started crying she was so apologetic.

Unfortunately, however, I can only draw one logical conclusion from these events: I can't trust her when she's drunk. This is a problem because she's an absolute sweetheart when she's sober. I really don't know what to do about this. I do know that if she slept with someone else, I would cut things off with her because just the knowledge of it happening would turn hanging out with her into a very unpleasant experience for me. I should probably start spinning other plates, but I know it would break her heart (she has told me she couldn't handle me sleeping with someone else), and I already stopped dating a few other girls because they didn't interest me nearly as much as this girl.

So anyways, what would you guys do when facing this kind of disrespect? Am I completely over-thinking this? Is there a possibility that she's playing me?
 

5string

Master Don Juan
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
2,364
Reaction score
112
Location
Standing At The Crossroads
Sounds like she is not telling you everything buddy. There must be more going on with her, just reading between the lines. If you want to keep her, I advise you to set clear boundaries. Such as, no messing with other guys, etc. Make it crystal clear that if she disrespects you, she's gone and you won't look back. I have done the boundary thing and it works. Good luck.
 

Iceberg

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 19, 2002
Messages
3,115
Reaction score
136
Age
43
Location
Manhattan, NY
She seems like a terrible person. If I read correctly, you said she made out with guys while you were at the same party? You said you don't care...but I mean....shouldn't you? If a girl i was dating made out with another dude at the same party I was at, I'd be pretty put off by this.

If she's a booty call, then okay fine. But if you care about her enough to start this thread, then you shouldn't be dating her anymore. She's bad news.

Trying to make a party girl into a decent woman is an exercise in futility. These chicks are meant to be banged, and moved on from. IF you wanna have some fun with her for 6 months until she moves, then go for it.
 

neil27264

Don Juan
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
13
Reaction score
2
Hi Hamilton, we have a saying un the Uk that alcohol just shows what's already there in someones personalliy hidden away. Sounds like she is playing games, and it's getting to you. Simple choice mate, put up with it or get out.
 

Allurre

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 14, 2008
Messages
661
Reaction score
19
I suspect she's the type that has problems with ACTUALLY remaining exclusive... otherwise there would be a stronger discipline with herself from having to make out with her 'orbiters.'

This is a part of her that needs to change, and you two should discuss it for the sake of the relationship's health. Otherwise... one night, everything will all go wrong.
 

pipe007

Master Don Juan
Joined
Mar 2, 2004
Messages
638
Reaction score
52
you know the saying
"if a girl kisses a guy in front of you, imagine what she does when you are not there"

Dude are you serious??????? you rewarded her past behaviros (kissing another guy in front of you) so she continues doing it, no wait, she sleeps with them too.

omg im hitting my head over here, I just cannot understand...

and you asking if you should trust her..... omg.

keep dating her, but just remember. In a couple months when your feelings for her increase just to find out she kept making out with random guys and most likely sleeping with them. what will you say then?

you are dating a trashy girl who has a tiny brain, has to be mentally retarded, and she does not grasp the concept of what the F!! it means to make out with random guys in front of the guy she is dating.... you have found yourself the lowest type of girl there is.... this is the type of girl who only hopeless guys with no game and a variety of mental disorders would date.
I dont think you are one of those guys

I WOULD RUN.
 

hamilton

Don Juan
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
52
Reaction score
1
To be fair, the 1st orbiter she kissed early on when we were still just messing around/having fun, and she claims the 2nd orbiter went in for the kiss on her (I believe her since if she wanted to lie she could have just not told me about it).

I think I am going to follow 5string's advice and lay down the law to her. Based on her reaction to that, I will decide what to do from there.
 

mikeyb

Senior Don Juan
Joined
May 10, 2007
Messages
475
Reaction score
16
Age
36
Location
UK
neil27264 said:
Hi Hamilton, we have a saying un the Uk that alcohol just shows what's already there in someones personalliy hidden away. Sounds like she is playing games, and it's getting to you. Simple choice mate, put up with it or get out.
Exactly. She's using alcohol as an excuse. You need to let her know that if she misbehaves again you're out.
 

5string

Master Don Juan
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
2,364
Reaction score
112
Location
Standing At The Crossroads
hamilton said:
To be fair, the 1st orbiter she kissed early on when we were still just messing around/having fun, and she claims the 2nd orbiter went in for the kiss on her (I believe her since if she wanted to lie she could have just not told me about it).

I think I am going to follow 5string's advice and lay down the law to her. Based on her reaction to that, I will decide what to do from there.
Good luck Hamilton. Let us know how it goes. I am married and was forced to set some boundaries with my wife. She knows exactly what the consequences will be should they be crossed. It's not like I'm holding a hammer over her head or anything. Just told her there are some things that are deal breakers. Some apply to me as well, so it goes both ways. Good luck friend.
 

BeyondCharm

Senior Don Juan
Joined
Apr 14, 2008
Messages
282
Reaction score
11
I have a similar story...

My GF at the time and I had been together far 5 months and she hadn't been drinking/partying much. She told me back in college when she partied she'd get drunk and fvck guys pretty much but she'd settled... well as soon as she started partying where I wasn't around she got drunk and banged her co-worker and started screwing him regularly... Obviously we're no longer dating... And this was after I had laid down the law/set boundaries/etc... she simply lied as women do to protect their image.

Girls like this, who are closet-alcoholics or just plain immature can't handle exclusive relationships.. It sounds like this girl is a HIGH risk factor for you...

You are welcome to take the risks and hope the rewards are worth it, but my suspicion is that given alcohol and a situation with another guy, she is going to screw someone else at some point.

Hope for your sake it's not your best friend LOL :D
 
Top