Thanks, str8up. People with e-commerce experience are telling me the same thing about paypal chargebacks.
The account he would paypal into has only $100 in it. I would not sign over the title until the bank would let me withdraw the actual cash. However, from what I am understanding, the chargeback can still occur. The bank would just give me a big negative balance in the account and try to initiate a collections process. I have no other assets at that bank.
If the only risk is having a bank after me for a collections charge, that is not so bad, because to get their money they have to litigate. And I would have no problem proving my innocence to a judge if it came to it. I will get a bill of sale, receipt of goods, as-is disclaimer, whatever other proof of sale that I need.
I am very wary of being scammed, but it is also reasonable that someone could have the plastic and not the cash. Maybe he is running up the card to file bankruptcy, who knows. I suppose the card could be stolen. I should make sure that it is in his name and ask to see a photo id, I am guessing.
Right now I am thinking to get the green money in hand, then litigate my way out of any problems later if it comes to it.