her sisters were hotter

[technickel]

Disclaimer: this is my first post here at DJ's, sorry if I don't understand all the acronyms yet.

I need some advice in case this situation happens again.

I hooked up with this girl a couple weekends ago, and this week her and her family just happened to be vacationing in the town where I live. I invited her and her sisters over for a BBQ with my housemate and I and some friends. The friends never made it, most of them are gone for the summer (school's out). So it was my hookup, her 2 younger sisters and my housemate (also male, but no where near DJ status). My hookup's younger sisters were hotter than her! Well sh!t. I chatted it up with all three of them, and we all had a good time. I really wanted to hook up with her youngest sister (19), a 3 yr difference in age that was probably more apparent to her, but I felt like I was stuck with the sis I had hooked up with earlier.

The question is: Would you try and hookup with the younger sister and face the potential drama that insued, or would you hookup with the girl you knew you could get a little action from?
If you did go for the younger sis, what strategy would you use?

thanks,
TeCHNiCKeL

 

[TheCloser]

If you could close the 19year old, who cares about the drama

 

[Krassus]

But then you risk losing all 3 of them. Then again, aren't risks what makes life fun?

 

[MDgood]

Dude, total disaster will ensue! Sisters TALK!!! The moment they suspect that you're coming on to all three of them is the moment you loose any chance of ever hooking up with any of them again.

 

[technickel]

If you could close the 19year old, who cares about the drama

It would have been nice to seal the deal with her, but I don't think I would have been able to get to that point with the other sisters around. Even if I got them all super drunk, there just werent enough people around to pull the youngest aside without the other two noticing. And like MDgod said, sisters talk. I think they already had a plan to get me to hook up with the oldest again.

Has anyone here been able to pull it off with girls who are sisters? Was it good times?

 

[mystik]

i think it cant be done, well not with quality girls. To them you are just a guy that passed through their lives and the sister is one they plan on having in their lives forever. Dont challenge the bond between sisters. Also you already hooked up with one girl, you will seem like a pimp who jumps at every better looking girl, which you are. What are the chances of closing on ANY of them after you showed them your cards?

 

[technickel]

mystik, I think you hit the nail on the head, thanks.

You guys all helped a lot. I look forward to learning and posting more. Now quit surfing the net and go get some

 

[MDgood]

Oh, God, please please please take my advice and be very, very, very careful!! How do I know this? I was trying the same thing five months ago and got burned like you wouldn't believe. Both sisters pretty much stopped talking to me.

In all fairness, though, I am seeing one of the sisters today, but it's the first time we've met up since I got burned, and it's in a social situation with her friends, it's not actually a "date" to my knowledge, and I'm the one who had to call her about it. But I doubt I got all that much of a chance, maybe just an opportunity to get the younger sister a bit jealous, who was hotter, too

 

[technickel]

MDgood,
It's cool dude. I don't think I'm really going to run into these girls again anyway. I agree that they talk and would definitely find their strength as sisters to be stronger than any guy they might be interested in. (or at least that's what they would tell each other) Don't worry about it. I've moved on. Thanks again for everyone who contributed!

 

[BobbDobbs]

It depends on how much interest the original sister had in you. I have relatives, two cute girls. A guy was dating one, but ended up marrying the other. No problem because the first girl wasn't interested in him.

 

[Captain Anonymous]

Damn I hate that.

Three times I've gone to a girlfriend's home, only to find that their sister is hotter than them.

And no, don't act upon it. Sisters DO talk, and they all know what one knows.

 

[Santos]

Originally posted by MDgood
Dude, total disaster will ensue! Sisters TALK!!! The moment they suspect that you're coming on to all three of them is the moment you loose any chance of ever hooking up with any of them again.

Exactly.