Got her but want her sisterrrr

[hb]

I made a mistake yesterday. There are two sisters that I know, I decided that I would go with the one that was a good friend of mine since she would probably make a better gf. So I told that one that I like her and I kissed her yesterday. Today I seen her sister and she looked AMAZING she looks much better than her sister and I feel that I made a mistake. What should I do? should i just tell her that I made a mistake and that I like her sister? Even if I do that, I doubt it will work. What do you guys think?

 

[Tyrone Biggums]

If you can't continue a relationship with the first sister then leave them both alone.

 

[diablo]

Originally posted by hb
What should I do? should i just tell her that I made a mistake and that I like her sister?

Better to have one than have none. If you back off from the first, she'll poison what the other thinks of you... the only way you can hope to have her sister now is to continue along in your relationship with the first, then work on her sister slowly - if she's attracted to you, there might be a time that you and her might just have a tumble between the sheets.

 

[check_mate_kid_uk]

no way, stay with her of leave her thats your choice, but if you want her sister unless there really sluty/desprate/dnt give a dam about each other then its a lost cause, i mena just put yourself in your girlfreinds sisters shows, would you go out with your brothers ex

 

[diablo]

Originally posted by check_mate_kid_uk
would you go out with your brothers ex

Nope, but given the right set of circumstances you might **** your brother's g/f. Girls are more apt to do this than brothers... bro's before ho's.

 

[jonny football hero]

The sisters i "did" didn't mind both going out with me.

You made your bed, now lie in it or leave it. Don't try and swap.

 

[quest]

just start kissing the other sister and be like if she says something just be all like.... errr i was kissing you last week? she'll be like, no it was my sister, and u'll be like, oh i thought it was u..


nah honestly, i think ur pretty well screwed like the other guys are saying..
i wouldn't mind banging my ex girlfriends sister, shes pretty cute, but i can't imagine it happening..
maybe if i was to run into her in 2 years? but its not worth seperating the sisters by making them fight over u.

 

[Chemistry]

Personally... I would explore what you've got yourself into and see where it takes you

The best way to exert value to the sister you really want is by being with the sister you chose... and as a side who knows you may find you actually made the right choice if you have any plans for an LTR which is suggested by the fact you looked at these girls as who would make the better GF

When things fall apart then you may have your opportunity with the sister... nothing is guaranteed because it depends on how the sisters are with each other... sometimes they need to be total enemies for one to consider seeing their sisters ex BF especially if you did her sister wrong or are perceived as doing so... in some cases for the slutty girls you pissing off her sister will make you even more attractive... on the other hand some sisters share like crazy and there would be no barriers at all to you seeing the other, but if they've got that bond then your attempts with sister #1 need to have fallen apart naturally or at least seem to have...


End of the day, this is one of those situations where you'll never actually know until you get into it! I know most are but this especially so... best of luck

 

[ShizamDaMan]

Threesome

But seriously, I've been in the same situation. When I went for the older, hotter, smarter sister it didn't work out with either of them. Date this one now or lose them both.

 

[freeque]

be ethical. break it off with the first sister right away, but gently.

let some time pass, date many other women.

find a way to see other sister accidentally, and alone, and if you still care, use your don juan moves on her then.

 

[Ice Cold]

My friend had a gf about a year ago. Then he got another one and double dated them for 2 months.

Turned out they were cousins.

So, one day the sisters decided to go to the movies together with their boyfriends. The guy first chickened out, but then decided to show up.

Imagine their astonishment when they found out that the "boyfriend" belonged to both of them.

Needless to say, they broke up

 

[Fenderules]

AHAHAHA

thats sweet! lol that would have been funny to see that. I guess no matter what your F*cked up the ass with that.


1:wuts your bf name?
2: his name is John
1:WOW! mine 2!
2: no way!
1: yeah way!
2; wut does he look like?
1: tall dark and sexy
2: O.......MY.........GOD me 2!
1:wow its like we have the same bf!
2:yeah lol like that would happen!

 

[pff]

FORGET THE SISTER. There is no way that this is going to work. Even if the sister falls for you, your GF will stop her. It's a lose-lose situation, so try to be happy with what you got instead of acting greedy.

 

[Fenderules]

yeah unless your a ture Don Juan master, i dont think it can be pulled off

 

[hb]

I find it funny about 5 years later looking back at this, me and the "sister" had a relationship that lasted about 8 months.. wow time flies

 

[Pathgen]

Unforgivable in my opinion. They are sister's which means that regardless if you can pull one into bed your going to be damaging their relationship. For what? It sounds like you dont care about either girls if your willing to jump between them. At least you don't care yet. Imagine if you had a brother and your girlfriend told you that she wanted to date him instead. You would have to forgive him because he is your brother, but its a pretty bad situation to put siblings through just to get some tail.

 

[hb]

She wasnt my girlfriend lmaoo just a girl that I kissed and thats rarely as serious as u think it is dude but I did end up having a wonderful relationship that ended in 2006 and began in july of 05 if you look at the dates I posted this stuff and her sister was constantly around.... just had other guys she was concerned with lol

 

[Pathgen]

lol i didnt read the whole thread. However, i still stand by my original opinion that if you had went after the sister it could have potentially created a really bad rift in their relationship. Because it is not necessarily that she would be pissed over you two getting together, but rather the betrayal of her sister. At least thats how i would feel if my bro did that. Thats all i meant

Im glad it all worked out for you and you had a good relationship. Yeah i am still pretty new to the site, but it is always fun to look back at your old questions and see how much you have changed or just for nostalgia

 

[LDBaha]

Watch that episode of Seinfeld the switch
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-xr...4E5A3C42&playnext=1&playnext_from=PL&index=67

Try that! hahhaha

 

[pua1989]

wait..was the relationship with the hotter one or with the one you originally kissed?