AmsterdamAssassin's gonna come in here and say something, but I'm going to give a different recommendation.
Since I don't know your personal style, the safe suggestion would be to not go with either of those options and instead opt for one of the more classic options like a dress watch or a diver. AmsterdamAssassin has a unique style he clearly cultivated for himself, so trying to copy individual pieces of his look could lead to a lot of awkward fashion mistakes.
Can't go wrong with straight up classic men's fashion. But we could probably make better suggestions if we knew what your outfits usually looked like.