Polishing A Turd Into A Diamond

soulforge

Master Don Juan
Joined
Aug 1, 2013
Messages
6,189
Reaction score
4,933
I strongly advise against it.

Too many guys are meeting girls who have a bunch of bad traits & red flags upfront, then they resort to try to change her into a better suited partner by setting boundaries on her.

I learned this the hard way myself. This strategy is setting yourself up for failure.

Can it occasionally work?
Yes, but the odds are stacked against you.

The vast majority of girls you will meet, will come with a certain amount of baggage & some of these minor issues can indeed be ironed out by setting some firm boundaries.

However girls that have significant bad traits, such as a party girl, or she has lots of male friends, has a promescious past or drinks too much alcohol.. You can forget about trying to get her to quit all these things.

It's likely in the honeymoon period, while her interest level is high, she might give up these bad habits, however overtime when she becomes more comfortable & secure in the relationship, or you become a little complacent with your boundaries, watch how quickly she falls back into her previous lifestyle.

You will have no choice at this late stage in the LTR but to walk or stay & tolerate it.

The only area where I believe in 2024 us men will need to compromise & set some boundaries, is Social Media.

If she is heavily into Social Media, I believe it's possible to set some boundaries & ask her to limit her online presence.. Why? Because they are ALL on social media. We cannot get away from this reality. There is no escaping this shyte in the Western world.

So moral of the story is.. Stay away from poop.. If you want a diamond in your life, then seek a diamond.
 
Last edited:

Dr.Suave

Moderator
Joined
Mar 6, 2017
Messages
3,823
Reaction score
4,140
I guess I agree with most of what you have said. Even if someone here claimed "I LTR/Married a former carousel rider and we been together for 30+years" or something like that, he would be the exception rather than the rule.

It's likely in the honeymoon period
...and/or The Epiphany Phase

However overtime when she becomes more comfortable & secure in the relationship, or you become a little complacent with your boundaries, watch how quickly she falls back into her previous lifestyle.
Yes, its like @Gamisch said: 99% of women can hear the Carousel calling, especially if she has already been there before.
 

Redwood

Senior Don Juan
Joined
May 4, 2014
Messages
327
Reaction score
126
Location
Houston, Texas
I'm getting older, so my tolerance for the bs and mind games are getting lower day by day, so I'm with you on advising against doing what you've stated.
 

soulforge

Master Don Juan
Joined
Aug 1, 2013
Messages
6,189
Reaction score
4,933
I'm getting older, so my tolerance for the bs and mind games are getting lower day by day, so I'm with you on advising against doing what you've stated.
One thing you will never get back, is time..

Don't waste it on trying to fix broken & lost Woman.
 

buddhafukko

Don Juan
Joined
May 23, 2017
Messages
84
Reaction score
73
Age
49
If you want a LTR, especially with children, giving a chance to an otherwise attractive overweight woman can work. For better or for worse, women who were overweight during their formative years tend to have very feminine qualities, including modesty, or you could say insecurity. It's easy to actually teach a woman to lose weight and reach her potential both aesthetically and health-wise, they will appreciate you for it. It's next to impossible to change a hot girl's rotten personality.

Some of the hottest 30 something women I dated had been overweight through their 20's. When they finally shed the weight they had it all.
 

BeExcellent

Master Don Juan
Joined
Dec 16, 2015
Messages
4,723
Reaction score
6,708
Age
55
If you want a LTR, especially with children, giving a chance to an otherwise attractive overweight woman can work. For better or for worse, women who were overweight during their formative years tend to have very feminine qualities, including modesty, or you could say insecurity. It's easy to actually teach a woman to lose weight and reach her potential both aesthetically and health-wise, they will appreciate you for it. It's next to impossible to change a hot girl's rotten personality.

Some of the hottest 30 something women I dated had been overweight through their 20's. When they finally shed the weight they had it all.
I agree with this. The Hollywood film editor I dated for 18 months after having been divorced for a year did exactly the above with the second girl he dated post divorce. We were each other’s first post divorce relationship, ridiculous chemistry but bad timing to consider remarrying right away.

After we were no longer involved he got into what started as a LDR with a pretty blond college professor who was overweight from the Midwest. She is also 15 years younger than him and had only ever been intimate with her ex husband. Now. Juxtapose that Midwestern girl with Midwestern values with the hot snots and smoke shows in Los Angeles.

And this guy is tall, charming and handsome. He had LA types throwing themselves at him. But that wasn’t what he was interested in.

He just got engaged to this girl. They’ve been together now 5+ years and share residences in CA and the Midwest. She’s working on weight loss & fitness now but has always been very feminine according to him. His family adores her.
 

MatureDJ

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 30, 2006
Messages
11,295
Reaction score
4,664
If you want a LTR, especially with children, giving a chance to an otherwise attractive overweight woman can work. For better or for worse, women who were overweight during their formative years tend to have very feminine qualities, including modesty, or you could say insecurity. It's easy to actually teach a woman to lose weight and reach her potential both aesthetically and health-wise, they will appreciate you for it. It's next to impossible to change a hot girl's rotten personality.

Some of the hottest 30 something women I dated had been overweight through their 20's. When they finally shed the weight they had it all.
Chicks gaining weight is almost like that law of thermodynamics that says that heat can only flow from hot to cold. :rolleyes:
 

Velasco

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jan 25, 2021
Messages
1,273
Reaction score
1,412
Age
31
It's likely in the honeymoon period, while her interest level is high, she might give up these bad habits, however overtime when she becomes more comfortable & secure in the relationship, or you become a little complacent with your boundaries, watch how quickly she falls back into her previous lifestyle.
Then don't become complacent with your boundaries.
 

Learning Curve

Master Don Juan
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
509
Reaction score
421
Age
32
Location
Cyprus
I strongly advise against it.

Too many guys are meeting girls who have a bunch of bad traits & red flags upfront, then they resort to try to change her into a better suited partner by setting boundaries on her.

I learned this the hard way myself. This strategy is setting yourself up for failure.

Can it occasionally work?
Yes, but the odds are stacked against you.

The vast majority of girls you will meet, will come with a certain amount of baggage & some of these minor issues can indeed be ironed out by setting some firm boundaries.

However girls that have significant bad traits, such as a party girl, or she has lots of male friends, has a promescious past or drinks too much alcohol.. You can forget about trying to get her to quit all these things.

It's likely in the honeymoon period, while her interest level is high, she might give up these bad habits, however overtime when she becomes more comfortable & secure in the relationship, or you become a little complacent with your boundaries, watch how quickly she falls back into her previous lifestyle.

You will have no choice at this late stage in the LTR but to walk or stay & tolerate it.

The only area where I believe in 2024 us men will need to compromise & set some boundaries, is Social Media.

If she is heavily into Social Media, I believe it's possible to set some boundaries & ask her to limit her online presence.. Why? Because they are ALL on social media. We cannot get away from this reality. There is no escaping this shyte in the Western world.

So moral of the story is.. Stay away from poop.. If you want a diamond in your life, then seek a diamond.
Diamonds are hard to find.

But better to find a diamond than a dirt. Filtering here is key.

Having a strong sensor and self-awareness of situations and advanced filtering of chicks that are sh1t and chicks that are quality.
 

LTG71

Master Don Juan
Joined
Aug 12, 2022
Messages
545
Reaction score
737
I just love the title of this post. This speaks to the vetting process. The notion that you can change someone’s childhood programming is a fool’s errand. We are under the influence during the ”honeymoon” phase but eventually those drugs wear off and you realize this person is actually a turd. Men and women both fall in love with the fantasy of who this person could be and not who they actually are. Starting to realize in old age that this is some form of narcissism. As in, the person you are looking for is a reflection of yourself but in the opposite gender. Women do this kind of non-sense for example when they pick a “bad boy” that they think they can fix with her influence. Waste of time. Sure, people can grow over time but you don’t want to start with someone from ground zero with a foul stench. When you see the red flags, don’t ignore them.
 

soulforge

Master Don Juan
Joined
Aug 1, 2013
Messages
6,189
Reaction score
4,933
I just love the title of this post. This speaks to the vetting process. The notion that you can change someone’s childhood programming is a fool’s errand. We are under the influence during the ”honeymoon” phase but eventually those drugs wear off and you realize this person is actually a turd. Men and women both fall in love with the fantasy of who this person could be and not who they actually are. Starting to realize in old age that this is some form of narcissism. As in, the person you are looking for is a reflection of yourself but in the opposite gender. Women do this kind of non-sense for example when they pick a “bad boy” that they think they can fix with her influence. Waste of time. Sure, people can grow over time but you don’t want to start with someone from ground zero with a foul stench. When you see the red flags, don’t ignore them.
Excellent post.

Most young woman in current times are raised in dysfunctional households, raised by single moms, indoctrinated by social media.

They believe riding cawks is just normal behaviour & all girls do this in their prime years.

I like how you stated, how often we are stuck on the fantasy of what that person could or should be.. And ignore who that person actually is.

The red flags are clearly telling you who they are.. Again as I stated in my original post, nearly everyone you will meet will has some red flags

We simply need to recognise the tolerable one's and eject when we see the serious ones.

If the girl was raised in a dysfunctional family & has a bunch of trauma, high body count etc.. You can forget about fixing that.
 

EyeBRollin

Master Don Juan
Joined
Oct 18, 2015
Messages
10,696
Reaction score
8,638
Age
35
You have two nephews; one is 5’6 and one is 6’6. Which one would you push to become a basketball player?

Point is; you have to start with a woman that already has the goods. She’s bred to be a wifey. Stable family, good discernment, upbringing, and discipline.

Don’t go shopping for a wife in the strip club…
 

BackInTheGame78

Moderator
Joined
Sep 10, 2014
Messages
14,567
Reaction score
15,684
You have two nephews; one is 5’6 and one is 6’6. Which one would you push to become a basketball player?

Point is; you have to start with a woman that already has the goods. She’s bred to be a wifey. Stable family, good discernment, upbringing, and discipline.

Don’t go shopping for a wife in the strip club…
Just listen to That Kid LEROI tells you in his songs...

"So there you go...oh,
Can't make a wife out of a ho"
 

Giovanni SouthSide

Master Don Juan
Joined
Aug 5, 2022
Messages
676
Reaction score
941
Age
33
Location
Tijuana, Mexico
While all women are indeed impressionable, they are not playdough.

Anyone who is an adult has already had all of their formative years spent being raised by certain people in certain environments with certain influences.

You can't make every chick like you and treat you how you want by being "alpha" and "controlling frame." Don't expect to change women. What you can do is weed out the ones that don't fit your tastes.

Some girls are just disrespectful, crass, selfish, and unappreciative.

Some girls are not feminine ladylike or graceful.

Some girls have poor ethics and morals.
Etc.
It's not your task to try and "change" them. You just make it clear what you want and see if they follow suit or not. If you're not enjoying a woman then drop her and find others.Throttle your options.

“Chicks are the first to fall in love
First to want to be exclusive
And first to want to be out

Hallowed is the player who gets into something and ends it. The player m.o. is to avoid the tie down in the first place, because breaking up a relationship is too mentally and emotionally taxing”
 
Last edited:
Top